Shrimp surimi-based products (SSPs) are composed of minced shrimp meat and are highly susceptible to fraudulent substitution by cheaper fish surimi.
This study (open access) employed a double-gene metabarcoding approach to authenticate SSPs sold in bulk (business-to-business) on Chinese e-commerce platforms. 16S rRNA and 12S rRNA genes were amplified and sequenced from 24 SSPs. Mislabeling was evaluated based on the correspondence between the ingredients (only those of animal origin) reported on the products’ labels and the molecular results.
The authors found that 21 of the 24 products were mislabeled. The replacement of Penaeus vannamei with other shrimp species was particularly noteworthy. In some samples the primary species detected in terms of sequence abundance were not shrimp but fish, pork, chicken, and cephalopods. The 12S rRNA sequencing results revealed that fish species like Gadus chalcogrammus, Evynnis tumifrons, and Priacanthus arenatus were added to some SSPs in significant proportions, with certain products relying on fish priced from “Low” to “High” levels to substitute higher-cost shrimp. Notably, many fish species in SSPs were highly vulnerable to fishing, raising sustainability concerns.
The authors conclude that the high mislabeling rate, as well as the detection of endangered fish species (Pangasianodon hypophthalmus), underscores significant quality control and supply chain integrity issues.
Photo by Fernando Andrade on Unsplash
